Heritage Cases

THIS IS THE ARCHIVE FOR SAHRIS 1.0


THIS SITE IS NOW AN ARCHIVE AND IS NOT SUITABLE FOR MAKING APPLICATIONS

Please be aware that no content and application creation or changes to information on this version of SAHRIS will be retained.

To make applications or utilise SAHRIS for the creation of information, please use the new site:

https://sahris.org.za

Changes to SAHRIS!

The South African Heritage Resources Information System (SAHRIS) has undergone a generational upgrade and restructure. These changes to the site include, but are not limited to:

  • A new & modernised look and layout
  • Improved site usage flows with respect to applications and content creation
  • Improved site performance and stability

Launch for the new version of SAHRIS occurred on Monday the 30th of October 2023.

The new site can be found here:

SAHRIS | SAHRIS

SAHRA Application Closure

Please note the following concerning applications submitted to the South African Heritage Resources Agency (SAHRA) during the December 2023 to January 2024 period.

The full notice is available here: Notice

Special Notice

Following comments received on the proposed Revised Schedule of Fees for applications made to the South African Heritage Resources Agency (SAHRA), made in terms of Section 25(2)(l) of the National Heritage Resources Act No. 25 of 1999 (NHRA) and published in the Government Gazette of 22 July 2022, SAHRA hereby publishes the final Revised Schedule of Fees for Applications made to SAHRA. Applications for provision of services submitted to the South African Heritage Resources Authority (SAHRA), in terms of the National Heritage Resources Act, No. 25 of 1999 (NHRA) must be accompanied by a payment of the appropriate fee, taking effect from 1 January 2023

Revised Schedule of Fees for Applications made to the South African Heritage Resources Agency (SAHRA)

Alterations to 200 Montpelier Road Berea, Durban

CaseViews

CaseHeader

Status: 

HeritageAuthority(s): 

Case Type: 

Development Type: 

ProposalDescription: 

Proposed alterations on ERF 792, 200 Montpelier Road, Berea, Durban, eThekwini, KwaZulu-Natal. Drawing SB001 and SB002

Expanded_Motivation: 

Architectural significance: The house is a good Edwardian house, well planned and built (originally) although some insensitive alterations have taken place over the years. The original elements remain intact, the alterations have failed and require serious refurbishment. The house has a positive relationship with the street and this feature should be maintained. Urban setting and adjoining properties: House with strong relationship with the street and its neighbouring house. The house overlooks the street and the boundary wall is kept transparent to enhance this relationship. The upstairs veranda on the west elevation overlooks the street and the relationship is positive. Other houses along this part of Montpelier rd have the same relationship and there is character in the urban form.There is a block of flats on the property to the south (next door) and this has a negative influence on the amenity usage of this property due to the fact that the flats overlook and have a contrasting form and use to the other houses on the street. 1 Lifestyle. The amenities of the property are compromised as the house had few, small bathrooms originally, then as an institute many small bathrooms were inserted. The alteration to the main house seeks to rationalise the bathrooms and allow en suit facilities to be provided. This involves the enclosure of the SE veranda with patio doors and the removal of a poorly excecuted extension circa 1970 (unknown) 2 Maintenance and condition. The alteration to the SE elevation on the first floor circa 1970 was poorly built. Bathrooms installed at that time have leaking plumbing, this has caused windows to rot and mould to grow uncontrollably. Damage is extending to timber floors and skirtings and structural masonry. The outbuilding roof has collapsed and requires full replacement. It is dangerous to the owner and neighbours. 3 Poor planning / design The extension of the rooms mentioned above involved the building of 45degree bay windows, with cottage pain casements, and the narrowing of the upper veranda. Access to this veranda was limited. These bay windows are not in fitting with the original bays on the house that are 90degree with sash windows. These windows have all rotted as they are of poor quality and have been destroyed by the damp of the poor plumbing. The alteration seeks to rationalise the plumbing, remove the bay windows and incorporate the veranda space to the interior so that the amenity of this space can be ennjoyed by the owner. Outbuilding Outbuilding 1 - replace roof and add lean-to to shade and protect entrance doors. new roof to be corrugated iron. cottage look of outbuilding is maintained. rotten doors and windows replaced with larger suitable timber elements to allow natural daylight and ventilation into the room. This building is internal to the property and not viewed from the street. Internal spaces are rationalised as there are too many toilets etc - from the days as an institute. Outbuilding 2 - replace roof with concrete slab for future planted roof / 2nd level accommodation Internal space planning Replacement of all rotten timber framed windows. enclosure of SE veranda with patio doors Removal of SE bay window walls - all poorly built, rotting and very ugly alteration. it is clear by the flooring, section of the house and manner of build that the house was extended half way onto this veranda in the past. This initiative aims to make the veranda space accessable again and restore the original quality of the elevation.

ApplicationDate: 

Tuesday, February 18, 2014 - 10:18

CaseID: 

4823

OtherReferences: 

ReferenceList: 

Images
south eastern and north western elevations don't have a strong relation to the street and are protected and shaded by large trees. This also allows for privacy in tighter spaces.
The south eastern elevation is not exposed at street level.
The existing elevation from the service alley.
The proposed alteration on the South East elevation doesn't front the street and a view from the interior space doesn't make any connection with the street.
The bedroom's windows and wall are to be demolished and a new 6mm safety glass aluminium framed curtain wall installed directly behind the doric columns. Existing wooden balustrades kept.
The bedroom's windows and wall are to be demolished and a new 6mm safety glass aluminium framed curtain wall installed directly behind the doric columns. Existing wooden balustrades kept.
The additional beam which extrudes from the wall is evidence that the house has been further developed structurally after the original plans were passed. This beam doesn't appear on the original plans of the house.
wooden flooring has been altered. Seen on section AA - one can see that an additional floor has been added to the existing structure.
The ceiling and plumbing are in a bad condition and need to be replaced.
The beam separates the old and new addition of the house.  One can clearly see that the house has been altered.
 
 

Search form